 |
UIA |
 |
RESULTS OF THE THREE BARCELONA COMPETITIONS
The organizers of the UIA World Congress Barcelona 96 launched a series
of international competitions open to architects and architecture students,
as a means of promoting architectural solutions aiming to enrich the debate
on the role of architecture in the transformation of the contemporary city.
Based on the Congress theme of Present and Futures. Architecture in Cities,
the programmes of these ideas competitons call upon architects to reflect
on and respond to the continual transformation of the urban fabric, the
insertion of new programmes into the city, the structuring and use of interstitial
or residual spaces. The sites proposed correspond to the specific present
day needs of the Catalan city and were chosen in concertation with the administrations
and institutions involved.
Three programmes and sites were proposed:
The results were officially announced on the Night of Awards, 4 July
1996, during the UIA Congress.
SERVICE AREA FOR THE LOGISTIC ACTIVITY ZONE
OF THE PORT OF BARCELONA
PROGRAMME
The Logistic Activity Zone (ZAL) of the port of Barcelona is a platform
of services for maritime transit and international trade, a place for storage
and distribution of goods as well as their quality control, packaging and
labelling. The programmme included designing the new entrance and access
points to the zone, the commercial service areas and also a vehicle and
driver service area.
JURY AND ADJUDICATION
194 projects were submitted to the jury which met in Barcelona from 7-9
June 1996. Presided by Alain Viaro (Geneva - Switzerland), UIA representative,
the jury was composed of Diana Agrest (New York - USA), Farshid Moussavi
(London - United Kingdom), Antonio Ortiz (Sevilla - Spain) and Ricard Pérdigo
(Barcelona - Spain), representative of the President of the Port of Barcelona.
After examining the comments and conclusions of the technical commission,
the Jury identified four types of approaches to the programme's aims:
- Projects informed by the definition of coherent orders at an urban
or territorial scale;
- Pragmatic organization which allowed for a flexible and adaptable development
of required and proposed functions;
- Building organization in accordance to the programme
- Projects which questioned the general programme development and exposed
the limitations of the competition.
WINNERS
First Prize (2 000 000 Pta):
- Jean-Lou Rivier (Lausanne - Switzerland)
Second Prize (1 000 000 Pta)
- Hiroshi Ninomiya and Kazuko Ninomiya (London - United Kingdom/Kanagawa
- Japan)
Third Prize (3 000 000 pta)
- Mathis Güller, Michael Güller, Daniel Niggli, Mathias Müller,
René Gälli (Zurich-Kilchberg - Switzerland)
- Herwing Kleinhalp, Thomas Pucher (Graz - Austria)
- Naoto Yaegashi, Gen Muraguchi, Hidetoshi Ohta, Kazuya Sakurai, Naotami
Yasuda (Sendai - Japan)
THE ENVIRONS OF THE BARCELONA FOOTBALL CLUB
PROGRAMME
Built in the late fifties, on the outskirts of Barcelona, the stadium
holds 120 000 spectators. The zone has undergone development to become
one of the city's most active sectors, with the university campus nearby.
Today it calls for restructuring, the programme and limits of which were
left open to the participants.
JURY AND ADJUDICATION
159 projects were submitted to the jury presided by Kristian Gullichsen,
architect (Helsinki - Finland), UIA representative, and composed of: José
Antonio Acebillo, (Barcelona - Spain), Rafael de Caceres, (Barcelona - Spain),
Roberto Segre, (Rio de Janeiro - Brazil), Josep Lluis Nunez, President
of the Barcelona Football Club, and Helle Juul (Copenhagen), deputy jury
member.
The jury identified three possible types of intervention:
- Maintaining the new current conditions and interventions in intermediary
spaces;
- Moving certain existing facilities;
- Redevelopment of the zone after elimination of current facilities.
WINNERS
First Prize (1 000 000 Pta):
- Manuel Scholl, Reto Pfenninger, Sabine V. Fisher, Claudia Thornet (Zürich
- Switzerland and Los Angeles - USA).
- Enric Battle, Joan Roig (Barcelona - Spain)
Second Prize (500 000 Pta):
- David Flo Tarruella and Francesc Lopez (Barcelona - Spain)
- Jordi Badia, Anna Pla Català, Javier Zumarraga, Laurence Liaw,
Miriam Ansari, Tony Leung (Barcelona - Spain).
Third Prize (300 000 Pta):
- Fabio Zlatich, Pietro Celli (Trieste - Italy)
- Iwata Shogo, Mori Yasuo, Kawai Rikiya, Baba Sinsuke, Matuoka Hirotada
(Osaka - Japan).
- Alex C. Ho (San Francisco - USA).
HOUSING AND PUBLIC SPACE IN THE HISTORICAL
CENTRE OF BARCELONA
STUDENT PROJECTS CONFRONTATION - UNESCO PRIZE 1996
The international Confrontation of architecture student projects, traditionally
organized as part of the UIA Congress, leads to the awarding of the UNESCO
Prize and various prizes offered by the UIA Member Sections.
PROGRAMME
The historical centre of Barcelona is the object of a far-reaching transformation
process stretching back to the mid-eighties with the aim of reassessing
some of the most run-down sectors of the city. The transformation involves
major reorganization of its fabric, building cultural facilities and rehabilitation
of a considerable number of homes.
The competition theme is on the construction of two adjacent blocks of
houses in the centre, public spaces and connecting areas. New housing models
adapted to the changes taking place in family structures and lifestyles,
the use and impact of new technologies and definition of public spaces are
questions which merit particular attention.
JURY AND ADJUDICATION
The jury met in Barcelona from 26-30 May 1996 and examined 1118 projects.
Presided by Adèle Naudé Santos (San Diego - Argentina), it
was composed of Wolfgang Tochterman, Director of UNESCO Human Settlements
Unit, Rifat Chadirji, (Kingston upon Tyne - United Kingdom), Manuel Gallero,
(Aachen - Germany) and Dietmar Steiner (Vienna - Austria); and deputy members
Sabine Kraft (Aachen, Germany) and Victor Perez Escolano (Seville - Spain).
After analysing the conclusions of the technical commission, the jury identified
a series of criteria for evaluating the projects:
- scale of the intervention;
- compatibility with environment and in particular with the immediate
buildings and open spaces;
- organization and interrelation of spaces;
- planning of residential units
- clear presentation of ideas or statement made by student
- aesthetic quality of proposed architecture
- novelty of ideas
WINNERS
- UNESCO Prize, (7 000 US$) awarded to Peter Abt (Bettingen-Zurich
- Switzerland);
- Japan Institute of Architects (JIA) Prize ( 5 000 US$) to Juan Gabriel
Garcia, Paula Cardells, José M. Flores, Juan Marco, Clara E. Mejia,
Chelo Penadës (Valencia - Spain)
- Superior Council of Colleges of Architects of Spain (CSCAE) &laqno;
Pérez Pinero Prize » (study grant of 500 000 Ptas) to Michal
Sulo (Vrbové - Slovakia).
- Royal Institute of Dutch Architects (BNA) Prize, (3 500 US$), awarded
to a project for the quality of a public green space by Juan Arregui Lopez,
Maria Fernandez Torrado (Spain)
- UIA Nordic Section Prize (15 000 Danish Crowns), to Cristina Diaz-Moreno
(London - United Kingdom)
- Federation of German Architects (BDA), study grant of 3 000 DM, to
Samuel Tamisier, Laurence Narce (Montpellier - France).
- Technical Chamber of Greece Prize (1 000 US$) to Yazmin Crespo (San
Juan, Puerto Rico - USA)
- Order of Architects and Engineers of Beirut Prize:
(1 000 US$) to Nami Komatsu, Naoki Sonoda, Atsumi Hayashi, Hiroyuki
Miyabe (Yokohama - Japan);
(500 US$) to Matsui Takashi, Toru Horiguchi, Takahide Aiba, Takumi Kato,
Tanaka Yasumichi (Sendai-Miyagi - Japan);
(250 US$ and a series of publications) to Blaz Kriznik, Gregor Gogevic,
Bojan Purg, Vasja Zupan (Ljubljana - Slovenia)
- Malaysian Institute of Architects (PAM) (1 000 US$) to Tim Kettler
(Montpellier - France)
- The Chamber of Architects of Turkey Prize (1 000 US$) to Tina Gregoric,
Alexandra Dolenc (Ljubljana - Slovenia)
- UIA French Section Prize (5 000 FF) to Jaime Sicilia Fernandez-Shaw
(Madrid - Spain)
- Union of Architects of Russia Prize (a ten day stay in Moscow and
Saint Petersburg) to Carlos Patricio Gonzalez (Spain)
- Slovak Architects Society (three weeks to a month's stay in September,
in Slovakia) to Günter Möller (Kaiserslautern - Germany)
- Union of Polish Architects (SARP) Prize (a two week stay in Cracow,
Warsaw, Wroclaw and Gdansk) to Silvia Ahrer, Verena Puchmayr (Vienna -
Austria)
- Association of Architects of Latvia (LAS) Prize (a six day study grant
in Latvia for two) to Astrid Wuttke, Daniel Macholz (Barcelona - Spain)
- Chamber and Association of Hungarian Architects (MEKES) Prize (a six
day study grant in Hungary) to Michael B. McKAy (Lexington-Kentucky - USA)
- Two flights to a continental destination offered by IBERIA to Xoan
M. Mosquera Muinos, Ricardo Pariente Villasur (La Coruña - Spain)
- National Union of Architects and Civil Engineers of Cuba (UNAICC)
registration for the "Conservation and Rehabilitation of the Architectural
Heritage" course and subscription to Arch + journal) to Carles Casablancas
Bazalote, Marta Peris Eugenio (L'Hospital de Llobregat-Barcelona - Spain)
- A collection of books offered by The Royal Australian Institute of
Architects (RAIA), to Dominique Desmet, Jean Pierre Vinceslas, Guillemette
Karpelès (Paris - France) to Santiago Vinuesa Poza, M. José
Pacheco Manzano, Nuria Solé Tena, Ricard Torres Montagut (Cerdanyola
del Vallès-Barcelona - Spain)
- A collection of architecture books offered by the Vienna Centre for
Architecture (Austria) to Maria Asun Oses Alonso, Maider Alustiza Larranaga,
Irma Otegui Goiburu, Marta Palacios Garcia, Aitziber Rubio Ereno (Logronio-La
Rioja - Spain) to Roberto Soto, David Juarez, Joan Escofet, Nadia Casabella
(Barcelona - Spain)
- Subscription to journal Quaderns d'arquitectura i urbanisme,
a publication by the College of Architects of Catalonia to Guillaume Lecomte,
André Bernard (Brussels - Belgium).
EXHIBITION - PUBLICATION
A selection of the projects submitted for the three competitions was
exhibited during the UIA Congress from 1-7 July 1996 at the Reials Drassanes,
in Barcelona. A publication edited by the College of Architects of Catalonia,
in three languages (Catalan, English and Spanish) is also available from:
Col.legi d'Arquitectes de Catalunya
Plaça Nova 5
08002 Barcelona
T. (34.3) 301 50 00 - F. (34.3) 318 60 29